VinFast announced on May 12 a deal to sell its Vietnamese manufacturing business for 13.3 trillion VND ($506 million) and transfer approximately $6.9 billion in debt to a group of new investors. VFS shares have fallen roughly 12% since the announcement.
The strategic rationale is clear. Manufacturing costs were a primary driver of VinFast's $3.9 billion loss last year. Removing the factories and associated debt would make the company largely debt-free and allow it to focus on R&D, product development, and sales. The assembly plants in Indonesia and India, along with patents for its newest EV generation, are retained.
The governance concerns center on the buyer and the transaction structure.
The lead acquirer is Future Investment and Trading Development (FIRD), which will hold 95.5% of the manufacturing business once the deal closes by September. FIRD holds patents for VinFast's first-generation EVs and has registered capital of $4.6 billion. Days before the factory deal was announced, real estate businessman Nguyen Hoai Nam acquired majority control of FIRD. Nam is a board member of Vincom Retail, formerly Vingroup's shopping mall arm.
The transaction structure itself is unusual. The manufacturing business will first be acquired by three parties: Pham Nhat Vuong personally, FIRD, and a company called Ngoc Quy Investment and Trading Development. Ownership is then reshuffled so that only FIRD and Vuong remain. Ngoc Quy, whose name means "precious stone," exits with no final stake. The role of Ngoc Quy in the transaction structure is unresolved.
Vuong participates in the transaction as both buyer and seller.
Vingroup has no large institutional shareholders. Dragon Capital, one of the few foreign investors in Vingroup, described the transaction as a positive structural development on debt reduction grounds. Singapore-based auto industry analyst Mehdi Jaouadi at YCP said the strategic logic is sound but the governance elements have "red flags and question marks."
In 2021, Foxconn approached Vingroup about VinFast's production lines. No deal materialized. Vingroup stated it has no plans to sell manufacturing facilities to Foxconn or any other OEM.